- George W. Blodgett, 1887 to 1898
- Dennis Conklin,1898 to 1901
- James H. King, 1901 to 1909
- Edward T. Carroll, 1910 to 1921
- Edward Morrison, 1922 to 1925
- James L. Sullivan, 1925 to 1927
- John E. Armstrong, 1928 to 1930
- Patrick F. Rox, 1930 to 1937
- John J. A'Hearn, 1938 to 1939
- Patrick F. Rox, 1940 to 1950
- George H. West (Acting Chief), 1950 to 1952
- Robert F. Flanagan, 1952 to 1965
- Anthony C. Scavone (Acting Chief), 1965 to 1966
- Peter Pemberton, 1967 to 1986
- Kenneth E. King Jr., 1986 to 2003
- Robert J. Flanagan, 2003
- Edward F. Moore, 2003 to 2009
- Christopher J. Cole, 2009 to 2013
- Gregory J. Veitch, 2013 to 2019
- John Catone 2019
- Shane Crooks 2019-2023
- Tyler McIntosh 2023-Present
For more information please view the photos of the Police Chiefs of Saratoga Springs.